Matot-Masei: Where the Chase Stops

How do you outrun a past mistake when there's nowhere left to hide?

Like this episode? Leave us a review!

We'd love to hear your feedback and thoughts on this podcast! Please email us at Editor@Lubavitch.com or drop a comment below!

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:10

Have you ever felt yourself chased by a mistake you made, hunted and haunted by it? Like Jean Valjean in Victor Hugo's Les Miserables, who is relentlessly pursued because of a past choice. He spends decades turning his life around, doing good, and completely reinventing himself. Yet no matter how far he travels, he's hunted by Inspector Javet. The inspector isn't a villain, he pursues Valjean because the law demands justice, not forgiveness. For Valjean, then, the whole world becomes a trap. The chase never ends. Welcome back to Torin 7. I'm Bela Olydord, and this week we conclude the Book of Bamidbar with a double portion of Matot Massei. So I think it would be interesting to look at its arc and see where we were at the beginning of the book and where we are now at its end. As you probably remember, the Book of Bamidbar began in the wilderness, a vast, undefined space where the desert feels like absolute freedom, where there are no fences, no borders, no permanent addresses. And for 40 years the Israelites wandered through it. But the wilderness has no lasting structure. You can't build a society where there are no boundaries. So the Torah begins preparing the people for that transition, organizing the camp into precise coordinates around the Mishgan. And every one of the forty-two journeys listed in this parsha moves them one step farther from the lawless openness of the desert and one step closer to an ordered civilization. And now we reach the end of Bamidbar, the end of their travels where the people prepare to enter a world of defined boundaries. The Torah says, This is the land that shall fall to you as your portion, the land of Canaan with its various boundaries. And the verses that follow describe the borders of the whole of the promised land, north, south, east, and west. Then the Torah divides the land among the tribes, and then it zooms in further, identifying forty-two cities for the Levites. And then the Torah carves out one final boundary, the Irmiklat, the city of refuge. There were six of them, and each was a designated space where a person who is being relentlessly pursued for a mistake can cross into it and find protection from their avenger. And this was necessary because under biblical law, if a person took a life by accident, the closest relative of the victim, the Go El Hadam or the Blood Avenger, had the legal right to retaliate. So think of the Irma Clut as the ultimate firewall. The moment the killer stepped inside its boundary, the avenger's right to retaliate was suspended, and the killer was protected by the community. But they were required to live there under confinement until they stood trial to prove the death was accidental, and they had to remain within the city borders until the death of the high priest, a strange, fascinating condition all on its own. So the Irmaklat, the city of refuge, is how the earthly courtroom handles the crisis of an accidental killing. But there is a beautiful Midrash in the Psychta Dirac Kana that takes us into the heavenly courtroom and asks an even deeper question. What should happen to the sinner? In this cosmic trial, there are four distinct voices that respond. We have wisdom, prophecy, Torah, and finally the Holy One, blessed be He. First, wisdom answers out of the laws of nature. Let evil pursue sinners, says wisdom. The past must mathematically catch up to you. Then prophecy answers out of absolute justice. The soul that sins shall die. Cause and effect, says prophecy, must be ironclad. Then Torah offers a legal compromise. Let him bring a guilt offering, and the sacrifice will balance the ledger. And finally, the Holy One, blessed be he, gives his answer. Let him do chuvah, let him return, and he will find atonement. And notice that God's response is the only one that doesn't demand punishment. It demands a change of heart. But God also knows how the real world works. He knows that the rigid judgment of the law, the javez of reality, will still hunt a person down before they ever have the chance to change, to do shuva. So God steps into the map and carves out the city of refuge, the Ir Miklat, with clearly marked signs along the path. It's a physical intervention designed to give a person at the worst moment of their life somewhere to stand. The Lababa Chariba sees the city of refuge as a physical model of Torah itself, one of civilizations, institutions, an ordered world that one inhabits, where life is not diminished by its boundaries, but is made possible because of it and through it. The psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott arrived at the same paradox from a different direction. He observed that a person doesn't recover inside total unstructured freedom. They recover inside what he called a holding environment, reliable, contained, sturdy enough to hold what the open world can't. And think about it, without that containment, freedom isn't freedom, it's just exposure. Now, in our own lives, the Avenger chasing us may not be external at all. It's our own regrets, our mistakes, and the inner critic insisting that we're permanently defined by our worst moments. What stops that pursuit isn't more open space, but a boundary firm enough that the past finally has somewhere it must stop. We think of freedom as the total absence of limits, but the Torah suggests that a mistake can't be outrun inside the chaotic openness of the wilderness. In fact, the wilderness leaves a person exposed to the chase. A boundary offers life, but only to those who remain within it. The Book of Bamidbar ends with a defined place where the broken finds safety, and where boundaries are not the enemy of life, they are its cradle. That's Torah in seven for Matot Masse. If you'd like to go deeper, there's a companion study guide with Hebrew terms, sources, and additional readings for further learning at Torah in seven.substack.com. If you'd like to dedicate an episode in honor or memory of someone, you can email me at Torah in seven at gmail.com. Thank you for listening. Shabbat Shalom.